Burrfection

Sharpening & Maintenance

Naniwa Pro 3000 Review: The Polishing Stone That Cuts Like an 800

The stone formerly sold as the Chosera 3000, against the Shapton Pro 5000: fast, lively, and a beautiful satin finish.

By Burrfection EditorialSeptember 6, 2017Updated November 19, 20263 min read

This article contains affiliate links: I may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. How this works

▶️ Watch the full video

The short version

  • It cuts like a sharpening stone: a burr in three passes and two on very dull knives, the same as the 800.
  • Excellent feel and feedback. The Shapton Pro 5000 felt dead next to it.
  • A 3000-grit satin finish, not a mirror. I think that looks more professional.

The Naniwa Pro 3000 is the stone formerly sold as the Chosera 3000. I put it against the Shapton Pro 5000 in the first round of my polishing-stone tournament (0:00). Both are true splash-and-go stones: I only splashed them while setting up, and neither really loaded up.

A cut test after sharpening

Naniwa Pro 3000

This stone never stops amazing me (4:17). It felt like I was sharpening on an 800:

  • Speed: I dulled the knives with 20 strokes on a brick, and it still raised a burr in three passes on the first side and two on the second, exactly like the Chosera 800.
  • Feedback: excellent. You know exactly what the stone and the knife are doing.
  • Feel: such a pleasure that you don't want to stop sharpening.
  • Loading: none. I just wiped it down afterward (12:03).

Can it be your only stone?

If you touch up your knives every day or every week, this stone can probably handle that on its own (5:00). But you'll still want a 1000-grit sharpening stone for when a knife gets truly dull. The burr it raises is just a little finer than the 800's.

The Naniwa Pro 3000
The Naniwa Pro 3000

Shapton Pro 5000

I like that Shapton Pros are slim, very hard, dense and don't load up much (0:43). But this one surprised me:

  • Feel: sluggish, very dampened and, honestly, boring. I first thought it was me, so I switched sides and went back and forth. It was the stone.
  • Feedback: numb. I hardly knew what the knife was doing, and it felt soft even though it's a hard stone.
  • The upside: a very fine edge and a near-mirror polish. It even pushed cleanly through paper (9:12).

If you already own one, don't be disappointed. On its own it's a good stone; it just can't compare side by side.

Side by side

Here's how the two stones compared side by side (10:37).

Naniwa Chosera / Pro 3000Shapton Pro 5000
SpeedBurr in 3 + 2 passes4 + 3 passes
FeedbackExcellentNumb
FeelLively, a pleasureDead, unresponsive
Finish3000-grit satin5000–6000-grit near-mirror
LoadingNoneA little
ExtrasThin, easy to transport
Where to buyBurrfection StoreAmazon

Satin vs. mirror

The Naniwa leaves a satin finish with a very nice sheen and a clean, sharp edge (13:10). The Shapton gets close to a mirror, shiny enough to almost see the window frame in it. I prefer the satin look; I think it looks sharper and more professional. But it's your knife, so pick the finish you like.

The Naniwa Burrfection Edition 800 and 3000
The Naniwa Burrfection Edition 800 and 3000

Bottom line

The Naniwa won hands down (7:49). They're not even in the same league; the only thing the Shapton does better is a closer-to-mirror polish. For speed, feedback and feel, this is the best polishing stone I tested. Pair it with the Naniwa Pro 800 and you have the two stones I've recommended for years, now also available as my custom Burrfection Edition 800/3000 combo set.

Available at the Burrfection Store.

First access

Private drops, new knives and sales

Get them from Burrfection and our retail partners before anyone else. No spam; unsubscribe anytime.

Emails from Burrfection Inc. See privacy.

Keep reading