Naniwa Pro 3000 Review: The Polishing Stone That Cuts Like an 800
The stone formerly sold as the Chosera 3000, against the Shapton Pro 5000: fast, lively, and a beautiful satin finish.
By Burrfection EditorialSeptember 6, 2017Updated November 19, 20263 min read
This article contains affiliate links: I may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. How this works

The short version
- It cuts like a sharpening stone: a burr in three passes and two on very dull knives, the same as the 800.
- Excellent feel and feedback. The Shapton Pro 5000 felt dead next to it.
- A 3000-grit satin finish, not a mirror. I think that looks more professional.
The Naniwa Pro 3000 is the stone formerly sold as the Chosera 3000. I put it against the Shapton Pro 5000 in the first round of my polishing-stone tournament (0:00). Both are true splash-and-go stones: I only splashed them while setting up, and neither really loaded up.
Naniwa Pro 3000
This stone never stops amazing me (4:17). It felt like I was sharpening on an 800:
- Speed: I dulled the knives with 20 strokes on a brick, and it still raised a burr in three passes on the first side and two on the second, exactly like the Chosera 800.
- Feedback: excellent. You know exactly what the stone and the knife are doing.
- Feel: such a pleasure that you don't want to stop sharpening.
- Loading: none. I just wiped it down afterward (12:03).
Can it be your only stone?
If you touch up your knives every day or every week, this stone can probably handle that on its own (5:00). But you'll still want a 1000-grit sharpening stone for when a knife gets truly dull. The burr it raises is just a little finer than the 800's.

Shapton Pro 5000
I like that Shapton Pros are slim, very hard, dense and don't load up much (0:43). But this one surprised me:
- Feel: sluggish, very dampened and, honestly, boring. I first thought it was me, so I switched sides and went back and forth. It was the stone.
- Feedback: numb. I hardly knew what the knife was doing, and it felt soft even though it's a hard stone.
- The upside: a very fine edge and a near-mirror polish. It even pushed cleanly through paper (9:12).
If you already own one, don't be disappointed. On its own it's a good stone; it just can't compare side by side.
Side by side
Here's how the two stones compared side by side (10:37).
| Naniwa Chosera / Pro 3000 | Shapton Pro 5000 | |
|---|---|---|
| Speed | Burr in 3 + 2 passes | 4 + 3 passes |
| Feedback | Excellent | Numb |
| Feel | Lively, a pleasure | Dead, unresponsive |
| Finish | 3000-grit satin | 5000–6000-grit near-mirror |
| Loading | None | A little |
| Extras | Thin, easy to transport | |
| Where to buy | Burrfection Store | Amazon |
Satin vs. mirror
The Naniwa leaves a satin finish with a very nice sheen and a clean, sharp edge (13:10). The Shapton gets close to a mirror, shiny enough to almost see the window frame in it. I prefer the satin look; I think it looks sharper and more professional. But it's your knife, so pick the finish you like.

Bottom line
The Naniwa won hands down (7:49). They're not even in the same league; the only thing the Shapton does better is a closer-to-mirror polish. For speed, feedback and feel, this is the best polishing stone I tested. Pair it with the Naniwa Pro 800 and you have the two stones I've recommended for years, now also available as my custom Burrfection Edition 800/3000 combo set.
Available at the Burrfection Store.
First access
Private drops, new knives and sales
Get them from Burrfection and our retail partners before anyone else. No spam; unsubscribe anytime.
Emails from Burrfection Inc. See privacy.


