Burrfection

Sharpening & Maintenance

Naniwa Pro 800 Review: Still My Favorite Sharpening Whetstone

The stone formerly sold as the Chosera 800, head to head with the Shapton Pro 1000. Same speed, but a world apart in feel.

By Burrfection EditorialAugust 25, 2017Updated November 19, 20263 min read

This article contains affiliate links: I may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. How this works

▶️ Watch the full video

The short version

  • Just as fast as the Shapton Pro 1000: a burr in five passes on the first side and two on the second, on very dull knives.
  • A much better stone to sharpen on: clearer feedback, a quieter, more controlled feel, and a cleaner edge in my cut test.
  • Finer than its rating: I'd put it at 1000–1200 grit, not 800.

The Naniwa Pro 800 started life as the Naniwa Chosera 800; the Pro series is the same stone without the old plastic base. I tested the Chosera 800 head to head with the Shapton Pro 1000 in my whetstone tournament (0:01), and it's been my top pick at this grit ever since.

Naniwa Pro whetstones
Naniwa Pro whetstones

Why these two?

On paper, they're nearly twins: both are splash-and-go (no soaking), very aggressive, and very hard (0:22). But I don't think either matches its label:

  • Shapton Pro 1000: feels more like an 800 to me.
  • Naniwa 800: finer than 800. To be safe, I'd call it 1000–1200.

I judged them on speed, tactile feel and feedback, and left price out so the test stays about performance (2:28). For reference, I saw the Chosera 800 anywhere from about $75 to $150 and the Shapton Pro from about $45 to $70 at the time, depending on the seller.

To make it a hard test, I dulled both knives on a brick with about 15 strokes and extra pressure, duller than most of you will ever let a knife get (7:52).

Speed: a tie

Both stones raised a burr in about five passes on the first side and two on the second (12:10). Neither was faster.

Feel and feedback: the Naniwa, easily

  • Feedback: I always knew what the stone and the knife were doing.
  • Feel: slightly muted and quieter than the Shapton. On the Shapton it feels like steel on rock.
  • Control: even though it cuts fast, I never felt I was losing control or second-guessing my pressure. Watch the stropping at the end of the video: I'm faster and more confident after the Naniwa (15:26).

It was the first splash-and-go stone I truly enjoyed (12:32). Until then, I'd always have picked a soaking stone (10:47).

The Naniwa Pro 800 and 3000
The Naniwa Pro 800 and 3000

The Shapton Pro 1000: good, not great

To be fair to Shapton fans: it's a good stone (4:19).

  • Pros: very fast, thin and compact, easy to store and travel with, and it barely dishes.
  • Cons: I never felt at home on it. Because it's so hard and doesn't give at all, getting an even burr from heel to tip took more concentration (9:42).

Both load up very little; the Naniwa slightly less.

The cut test

On newspaper, both knives were very sharp, but the Naniwa edge was cleaner and more consistent from heel to tip (16:29). There's always some user error in a test like this, but it matched how the stones felt.

Side by side

Naniwa Chosera / Pro 800Shapton Pro 1000
TypeSplash-and-goSplash-and-go
Feels like1000–1200 gritAbout 800 grit
Speed5 passes + 2About the same
FeelQuiet, controlled, confidentHarsh, like steel on rock
FeedbackExcellentGood
BurrEasy to get evenTakes more concentration
Cut testCleaner, more consistent edgeVery sharp, less consistent
Where to buyBurrfection StoreAmazon

My Burrfection Edition

After about three years of recommending the Naniwa Pro 800 and Pro 3000 on my channel without any compensation, I visited Naniwa in 2019. Afterward, they offered me a custom design of those two stones (6:25). They have my name on them, but I recommended these stones long before that: they're the best I've used, even on knives up to 68 HRC.

Get both in one: the Naniwa Burrfection Edition Professional 800/3000 combo set.

The Naniwa Burrfection Edition 800 and 3000
The Naniwa Burrfection Edition 800 and 3000

Bottom line

The Naniwa won hands down (21:44). It matched the Shapton's speed, then beat it on feel, feedback and the edge it left. If you're building a whetstone kit, this is the sharpening stone I'd start with. Pair it with the Naniwa Pro 3000 when you're ready to refine.

The Naniwa Pro 800 is available at the Burrfection Store. New to stones? Read my whetstone grit guide.

First access

Private drops, new knives and sales

Get them from Burrfection and our retail partners before anyone else. No spam; unsubscribe anytime.

Emails from Burrfection Inc. See privacy.

Keep reading