Burrfection

Knife Reviews

Masamoto KS vs. Masamoto VG: Carbon Artist's Knife or Stainless Workhorse?

My two everyday knives from the same maker: White #2 carbon or easy-care stainless, a light wa handle or a heavy Western one, and which one suits the way you cook.

By Burrfection EditorialAugust 23, 2017Updated November 21, 20265 min read

This article contains affiliate links: I may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. How this works

▶️ Watch the full video

The short version

  • The Masamoto KS is a White #2 carbon steel knife for fine, dexterous work, with a flatter profile, a very light wa handle and a forward balance. It gets sharper, and it's my favorite.
  • The Masamoto VG is stainless, rocks more easily and feels more Western, thanks to its rounder belly and heavier handle. It holds a good edge with almost no upkeep.
  • In 2017 the VG cost about $160–190 and the KS 240mm about $320–330. Both are excellent; the KS is for people who see a knife as art.

A subscriber emailed me asking for the key differences between these two Masamotos. They also happen to be my two favorite knives, the ones I use every single day (0:03). The obvious difference is the handle, a Japanese wa handle on the KS and a Western one on the VG, but what matters more is how the blades feel day to day.

Two very different steels

In my opinion, the Masamoto KS is the best knife you can buy, at any price (0:46). A lot of high-end manufacturers model their knives on it, and I can name five or six major brands that say in their marketing that their knife was designed after the KS. It's a carbon steel knife made from Hitachi White #2, a very sharp steel that many high-end makers use.

Nobody seems to know exactly which steel the VG line uses; some suspect VG10, others VG5 (1:49). Either way, it's stainless, and it's a very good blade. America's Test Kitchen named the VG its favorite hybrid Japanese gyuto, up against knives from about $75 to $340, and the only knife it preferred overall was the Victorinox 8-inch chef's knife (2:12).

Profile: chopper or rocker?

Right away you can see the profiles are very different (2:35). The KS is made for fine cutting and dexterity. It has a semi-flat spot toward the heel and only a very slight belly, which is great for chopping, and its pointed, tapered tip makes slicing a pleasure. It can rock, but rocking isn't its strength. I'm much more of a chopper and slicer than a rocker, so it suits me.

The VG is much more rock-friendly (4:26). It has a bigger, rounder belly with only a slight flat spot near the heel, so it rocks well and can still chop. If you're coming from a Wüsthof or Henckels, most of your cutting is probably that rocking motion, and the VG will feel familiar.

Weight and balance

The balance between the two blades is similar, but the VG, a 240mm in my case, has a relatively heavy handle (4:48). That gives it a more Western feel, which is why my wife prefers it: it's closer to what she's used to. The KS has an extremely light ho wood handle, and its balance sits well forward, about a quarter to half an inch ahead of my pinch grip.

I know many people say the balance point should be right where the tang meets the handle. I disagree. I prefer the weight slightly forward, because a slightly heavier tip helps when you chop. When the weight is too far back, or perfectly centered, chopping isn't hard, just less pleasant (6:12).

Sharpening and edge retention

The KS tapers to a finer edge than the VG, so in the hands of a good sharpener, it will get sharper (6:53). White #2 is also easier to sharpen than stainless; that's broadly true of carbon versus stainless knives from any maker. The VG, though, is aimed at home cooks who won't sharpen every week. Its heavier blade holds a really nice edge for a long time, even if it doesn't get quite as sharp. I can't say it outlasts the KS, but it holds up very well.

In practice, I sharpened my VG only every two or three weeks, while I touched up the KS once or twice a week, because it's the knife I take pride in and I want it razor sharp every time (8:21). For daily use, the VG holds up just fine.

Rust and patina

A carbon blade like the KS will form a patina, and it will rust if you leave water on it (9:06). I keep my knives very clean, and personally I don't like patinas, though plenty of people force them with mustard, vinegar or lime juice. After each sharpening I clean the blade with 0000 steel wool, or with baking soda and a little water, which removes the patina with a chemical reaction. The quickest way is ultra-fine sandpaper or the steel wool. The VG is stainless, and I've never had any rust problems with it.

Price, and who each is for

In 2017 the VG ran about $160 to $190 depending on length, while the KS 240mm retailed around $320 to $330 (10:32). The VG is geared toward home cooks, though professional chefs use it too. The KS is a specialty knife for people who see a knife as art, and I feel it will grow with me as my cooking skills improve. Even after six months of using the VG, I still reach for the KS whenever I'm prepping a meal; the VG gets the quick jobs, like cutting up an apple or some broccoli (11:57).

Masamoto KSMasamoto VG
SteelHitachi White #2 carbonStainless (VG10 or VG5, uncertain)
HandleVery light wa (ho wood)Heavier Western handle
ProfileFlatter, slight belly, pointed tip: chopping and slicingRounder belly: rocking, can chop
BalanceForward of the pinch gripToward the handle
SharpeningEasier, gets sharperHolds its edge well with little upkeep
CarePatina and rust if left wetStainless, no rust worries
Price (2017)About $320–330 (240mm)About $160–190
Where to buyBurrfection StoreBurrfection Store

Bottom line

Beyond personal preferences about balance and handles, you'll be happy with either knife (12:17). And a good cook can use any knife, even a $50 one, as long as it's sharp. If you want an easy-care knife that rocks and holds its edge, get the Masamoto VG; see how it stacks up against a German classic in my Masamoto VG vs. Wüsthof Classic Ikon. If you love sharpening and want a knife that feels like art, get the Masamoto KS, and read why everyone wanted the KS. For more options, browse gyutos at the Burrfection Store and Gyuto.com.

First access

Private drops, new knives and sales

Get them from Burrfection and our retail partners before anyone else. No spam; unsubscribe anytime.

Emails from Burrfection Inc. See privacy.

Keep reading