Burrfection

Sharpening & Maintenance

Electric Knife Sharpener vs. Whetstones: Which Is Worth It?

A $150 Chef'sChoice-made electric sharpener against $150 of Suehiro whetstones, on Japanese knives at 62–63 HRC: speed, sharpness, scratches and repairs.

By Burrfection EditorialMay 5, 2018Updated November 19, 20264 min read

This article contains affiliate links: I may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. How this works

▶️ Watch the full video

The short version

  • For a beginner who just wants a sharp knife, the electric sharpener gives consistent results much faster. No weeks of practice.
  • Whetstones gave a far better edge, two to three times better by my judgment, plus they can fix chips and reprofile. The machine can't.
  • The deal-breaker for me: the electric sharpener left hairline scratches along the whole blade.

Lots of you have asked whether an electric sharpener is worth it, or if you should buy whetstones instead. So I tested both, at about the same price (0:00).

Testing the electric sharpener against the whetstones
Testing the electric sharpener against the whetstones

The matchup

Electric sharpenerWhetstones
WhatWüsthof-branded sharpener made by Chef'sChoice, 3 stagesSuehiro Cerax 320, Cerax 1000, Rika 5000 (soaking stones)
Price in the video$149 on sale, usually $179–189About $50–55 each, ~$150 total
GritsNot listed; my guess is the last stage is no finer than ~1500320, 1000, 5000
Sharpening timeA little over 5 minutesA little over 7 minutes (plus soaking)
Where to buyAmazonBurrfection Store

One limit of this test (1:05): I used knives at 62–63 HRC, because that's what I use most and what many of you ask about (0:22). This sharpener wasn't really designed for knives harder than 62, so results on softer German knives may differ.

Using the electric sharpener

I followed the manual exactly: 20 pairs of pulls in stage 1, one or two pairs in stage 2, three pairs in stage 3, then the final stropping pass at about one second per five inches of blade (1:47).

The good news first. It took about five minutes in total; the timed pulls make it slower than I expected, but that's still not a big deal. It's fairly quiet, and four large rubber feet kept it planted on a smooth steel table (2:35).

What I didn't love starts with the fact that you can't see the blade (2:57). The guides hide where the sharpening wheels are: pull too low and the knife cuts into the plastic guides, too high and you miss the wheel. I understand they protect your blade and fingers, but it frustrated me as someone who likes precision. The deal-breaker was the scratches: hairline scratches about half an inch above the edge, from heel to tip (4:26). Everyday scuffs look organic; this looks unnatural and unprofessional. And there's no chip repair. Minor pitting is fine, but for a 1mm chip from hitting a bone, the machine is useless (4:47).

Pulling the knife through the electric sharpener
Pulling the knife through the electric sharpener

Using the whetstones

The Cerax 320 is a great coarse stone, whether as a fixer or to bring a dull knife back. The Cerax 1000 is the one stone I'd recommend if you only want one: it fixes minor chips and gets a knife razor sharp, especially with a quick newspaper strop. And the Rika 5000 is one of my favorite polishing stones. It leaves a hazy kasumi finish, which I think looks more professional, and the edge is even sharper.

Without rushing, it took a little over seven minutes, not counting soaking (5:11). For soaking stones, I don't think anything beats these for the money, even up to $100 a stone.

The paper test

Straight off the machine and the stones, no stropping (6:20). The electric sharpener's edge on my Dalstrong was decent, about what I'd expect from a Cerax 1000 (7:33). The Rika-finished edge was cleaner, and you can hear the difference in the video.

Paper cut test
Paper cut test

Which should you buy?

Get the electric sharpener if you're just getting into knives and want a sharp knife without a learning curve (8:36). Out of the box, within 10–15 minutes of figuring out where the wheels are, you'll get a consistent edge. On whetstones, matching that could take weeks or months of practice.

Get whetstones if you want the best edge and more control. The edge is far better, two to three times better than the machine's in my judgment. Whetstones are portable, too: no power, just water, a knife and something to set them on. And they're more versatile, since you can fix chips and gouges and reprofile a knife, none of which you should try on the machine.

Bottom line

The electric sharpener is fine: fast, consistent, decent results (10:05). It just won't give you a whetstone edge, it scratched my blades, and it can't repair damage. If you're willing to learn, whetstones win; if you just want sharp knives with no learning curve, the machine does the job. Take my results as one test, not the final word.

New to whetstones? Read my whetstone grit guide and knife sharpening setup.

First access

Private drops, new knives and sales

Get them from Burrfection and our retail partners before anyone else. No spam; unsubscribe anytime.

Emails from Burrfection Inc. See privacy.

Keep reading